Building a Custom App vs. Off-the-Shelf Options: The Pros & Cons

Nowadays, many companies are choosing to develop a branded custom app—whether for customer loyalty programs, for eCommerce, or for a quick, portable information source. But how do you know whether to buy an app ‘off the shelf’ or invest in developing a custom app of your own? Fortunately, our crack team of developers is here to help you determine the best app development solution for your company.

When making a decision about your application solution, the first (and arguably, the most important) question you will find yourself asking is: What do I need this application to accomplish? Many times, the scale of your application, the resources you have at your disposal, and the complexity of the problem you are solving will dictate the solution you search for when buying an app or building a custom app.

Taking these into consideration, there are two main app development paths that most businesses will travel: the off-the-shelf option, or the custom-build. In order to aid you in determining the proper direction, we put together the pros and cons of each option, and the essential ingredients to inspect before diving into your development recipe.

Option 1: Off-the-Shelf App

Pros – With an off-the-shelf option, you’re getting a standard, cut-and-dry solution for a simple development need. The nature of the off-the-shelf application means that the app comes pre-built and fully functional. Imagine a nice 5 paragraph essay with a space left open for your name (or company logo) at the top.

This option is generally faster from the time you decide you need an app to when you’ve got it up and running. It’s also cheaper, in most cases, since the cost of the app development is spread across multiple companies who buy the white label version.

Cons – A cookie-cutter build like this will limit your ability to improvise and include specialized features. The creativity and uniqueness of the application are debilitated, and workaround solutions for newfound needs aren’t possible. The other fear is you license software from a vendor and realize that it is simply not suitable for your business.

A lot of businesses in today’s market shy away from terms like “cookie-cutter,” and rightfully so. No two businesses are alike and an app that works the same for everyone is, ultimately, not going to meet all of your business’ unique needs. That’s when it’s time to turn to a custom-built app.

Option 2: Custom App

Pros – Custom application development projects are built by starting with a framework. To give you some technical insight: this framework will supply you with a Model View Controller (MVC) setup that will handle the database connection (Model), the front-end (View), and the code behind the application’s logic (Controller). This option will be completely personalized and tailored to the needs of your business. If your app needs to have functionality with unique properties or needs to be scalable with your company growth, a custom build is key. Further than scalability and customization, this application build is much more likely to fit in with the software packages that you already use.

Cons – The time that it takes to make this happen is more extensive as it will need to be built from the ground up. You’ll also want to make sure that you contract your development team with long-term troubleshooting—as mobile operating systems evolve, you’ll need the ability to update your app appropriately.

The Upshot – Developing a custom app gives you the potential for that “wow” factor that pushes an application out of the good stage and into the great one.

In the end, the key question really comes down to the kind of application you’re looking for. What format suits your business needs? Imagine two different kinds of robots. Would you need a clean-cut gray android with yes-no answers to your straight-forward questions? Try out an off-the-shelf option. Now, if you’re looking for a rugged automaton that can shoot lasers out of his eyes, salsa dance, and speak Portuguese when the situation calls for it, consider a custom build.

At Pyxl we build custom applications suited to your unique brand. All the bells and whistles, widgets, WordPress workings, and more are at your disposal when our enterprise developers handle your web properties. If a tailored web application sounds like the right fit for you, contact us, and ask about the creative solutions we can craft for your digital needs.

Updated: Apr 13, 2022